The Practice of User Registration to Access Data
I am writing to address an issue that is coming up at UCLA with increasing frequency. More and more data distributors (agencies, archives, individuals) require a user to "register" before downloading data from a web site. These registrations take many forms and there is a continuum in terms of levels of detail and responsibility assigned to the user. It makes it hard for me to be of service to users when each study requires every individual to perform the registration task. Few archives will agree to any kind of blanket license so that the Archive can download the data one time and provide it to users at UCLA. Fewer still will permit me to be a gate keeper such as ICPSR acts for really secure data. I'd like to know how other archives handle these issues.Faculty chafe at the registration requirement and I am aware of numerous cases where one faculty member gets the file(s) and "shares" regardless of the agreement they have made with the data distributor not to do so. There is also a feeling on the part of faculty that increasing access barriers are adding to the cost of research. I am intrigued by this idea and I wonder if anyone has heard this argument as well. I would like to find data that can demonstrate this increase in cost - whether it is in time, staff costs, hardware or software costs, or other quantifiable aspects of research. Any suggestions would be welcome.Contributed by Libbie Stephenson
- administrator's blog
- Login to post comments
Comments
An interesting piece related
Many thanks again to everyone
Hi, To add to both comments,
On Tue, 13 Sep 2005, Laine
A wonderful discussion with
There is another concern
Under a principle/policy that
Sandy Shaw (EDINA, University of Edinburgh)
Shibbolising UK Census and ESDS services
Lucy Bell (UK Data Archive, University of Essex)
Speaking as an 'outsider' on
To add to the interesting
Hey Melanie, My thoughts
I think our users are more
are there pregnant women in the survey?
etc.
etc.
Well said! Keith Cole
Well, I think the situation
Glad you brought this up